Area characterisation:
Dis-connected community capital
Strong new communities and initiatives have emerged in Dublin as a response to the last economic crisis. Old challenges such as vacant spaces re-emerged. Creative people began to use these spaces in new and innovative ways. There are already many active community groups doing local projects and so many spaces with potential ideas. New initiatives often start from scratch rather than learning from groups that have already had that experience. This is because connectivity among communities is weak. Many communities told us that they experienced difficulties in navigating through administrative procedures. Information about public services was not easy to find. Public websites were text-heavy and compartmentalised. Hence all these public services needed to be accessed through one portal.
The challenge that we engaged with is how to make the abundance of community capital (*) visible and networked. How to audit vacant spaces through crowd-sourced information, how to find communities to collaborate with, how to help communities to find ways to navigate projects and how to create informal spaces for different organisations and communities to meet and network.
Dynamic communities, resources, and knowledge are in abundance in the city. However, there is no way of knowing about them unless someone tells you about it (High Context Society) and there seems to be a lingering perception that there are "not enough resources". The effects of a boom and bust economy created an interest for new uses in vacant spaces. Since the economic crash, there has been an explosion of groups and vacant spaces in the city with certain groups using its resources in innovative ways showing us the "adjacent possible". Over 600 sites were recorded on a preliminary map by Dublin City Council in 2013. There were many views on the number and type of vacant spaces in Dublin. What constitutes a vacant space? Was it possible to engage citizens through crowd-sourcing to find out more and share local knowledge about vacant sites?
While a large number of community groups is a good thing, it seems that new groups have a tendency to replicate existing ones. For instance, if a group sets out to address a particular challenge –such as lack of attractive green spaces– it often tends to start from scratch rather than connecting to existing communities that have already developed solutions and projects for that challenge. Despite their strong digital presence, communities tend to be isolated from each other and have so far not developed a "community of communities". In addition, many services in the local authority are not known to citizens. There is much knowledge among people within the local authority and between citizen groups that are not passed on.
The last period of economic expansion was spurred by immigration, at times in the form of returning Irish expats. Interestingly, many of these communities are not defined by geographical neighbourhoods like more traditional community groups. They reflect social or cultural bonds in a diverse population that span different areas of the city. Thanks to the work of these strong communities, there are lots of activities happening in all corners of the city. The groups tend to have a strong digital presence through websites and social media. These communities didn't require more expert help or more ideas on what to do. What they needed was connectivity among communities to share resources and knowledge.
- Who are these groups?
- Where are the vacant spaces located? How many are there? What are their characteristics?
- How can these resources be connected?
- What kind of communities are there? What activities do they do? How are they supported?
- How can communities activate spaces for local community use?
- If you have a community project, what would you need to know if you wanted to engage an artist?
(*) Community capital refers to the natural, built,social and human resources available to a community
Objective:
Connected we're a living city.
To strengthen connectivity between resources in terms of people, space, knowledge, and expertise. To make clear the "What" that exists, to represent the "Who" and reveal the "How" of connecting to resources -creating a more resilient city in which resources flow to communities that require them most.
What is the vision for the region?
The vision for Dublin is that it is a city where communities (*) are represented and visible to one another. The citizens have a space to find each other. They know how to find out about resources (for e.g. information on vacant spaces) and they are aware how to create their own community projects in the city. Decision-making processes are not hidden and consequently, service delivery is improved. With communities being more connected, resources can be directed to the right places, helping save energy and time. Assets such as space, knowledge, and expertise are used more efficiently. Improved connectivity would also facilitate communities to understand administrative and planning procedures to design their space to suit their needs.
(*) Communities - is not limited to grass-roots community groups and includes communities with institutional capacity, academics, social entrepreneurs and communities of practice.
- What is the vision involving community projects?
"We are very excited about the potential of this project to enable citizens to co-produce the city of the future." - Dick Gleeson - Dublin City Council. - How receptive is the community to this vision?
"We would be more than happy to be on your dashboard and to welcome new people into our group. At the moment we have no shortage of members and the benefit of your dashboard idea for us would be, perhaps, a more diverse group of people hearing about us." - Fióna and Anne - Dublin Writers' Forum
Context:
The variety of experiences, knowledge and social capital of diverse communities can be connected through tools that facilitate collaboration.
What are we dealing with?
- How could new systemic knowledge about challenges in Dublin be created?
"Instead of starting new projects from scratch, people could join existing groups that are already doing projects, contribute to them and learn from them." - Siobhan Maher, External collaborator
- How could online tools be used to facilitate that systemic knowledge?
"Our group would certainly be interested in the dashboard and would be happy to connect our website to such a portal. We've got a few people involved in our committee who would be happy to be involved hear more about this if there's anything you need or would like to pilot!" - Harolds Cross - Village Community, External collaborator
Financing:
No information
Potential impacts/benefits:
What is the strategy for the region?
Strengthening community capital through connectivity
The strategy taps into existing resources, diverse communities and their knowledge and interlinks them.
The strategy builds on the existing energy and resources from a diverse range of groups. Tools are created from information sourced from community groups and other communities (*). Volunteers and academic communities are involved in the creation of the tools. In this way, Dublin City Council is seen as a facilitator of community connectivity and not as a top-down coordinator. While the development of communication channels –including websites or simple apps– tend to be cheap or even free, maintaining and upgrading them are strategic challenges that the "community of communities" needs to address together. Also for social media, the forums would need to be moderated.
(*) Communities - includes community groups, communities of interest, communities of practice, institutions like Dublin City Council or the EU, universities and social entrepreneurs.
- What impact has this TURAS strategy had on local project leaders?
"The collaborative and experimental approach of TURAS has improved my understanding of the potential of community involvement to contribute towards a more effective planning strategy." - Myles Farrell - Dublin City Council - Why was the strategy brought forth?
"We collaborated on this idea because it was simple to create and could benefit communities in the city." - Volunteer - Code for Ireland. External collaborator.
Actions:
How do we implement the transition?
Networks between citizens and community captial
A series of new tools has already been piloted. These include the on-line community directory "Collaborations" and a crowdsourced web-mapping for vacant sites called "Reusing Dublin". The "ComPass" tool, currently in progress, is a road map that guides communities along the implementation process. The guide "So you're going to commission an Artist" shows communities how to engage an artist in collaborating with them and the observational project "Connect the dots" brought diverse communities together to network.
The tool Collaborations is an on-line communities directory that supports the first stage of collaboration by creating a virtual space where different communities can find each other. The directory acknowledges all types of communities such as grass-roots community groups, communities of practice, social entrepreneur groups, and institutional communities. It facilitates networking between groups. Click here to visit website
Reusing Dublin is a tool that uses crowd-sourced knowledge to audit underused spaces in order to identify opportunities for using the city more efficiently. Underused spaces include sites and buildings that are not used at all (vacant) or that are only partly in use. It also includes spaces that may have additional use, like a roof or a grassed area. Crucially, through its interactive format Reusing Dublin taps into the knowledge and preferences of local communities rather than trying to identify underused assets through a centralised procedure. Click here to visit website
Another tool that is in process is Compass, a "how to" guide for doing a wide range of community projects centred around using place. It organises and documents community experiences on previous projects that provide guidance to other communities. It acts as a "social memory" that facilitates communities to build on existing knowledge and experience rather than start projects from scratch. The information compiled in Compass is presented in the form of 9 steps with case studies presented in the form of "theory of change". Click here to visit website
The guide "So you want to work with an artist?" is a guide for community groups who would like to engage an artist to work collaboratively on their community project.
Connect the dots was an observation project that TURAS supported and evaluated. It attempted to bring together different communities into a network. Click here to visit website
- What impact does this project have?
"It would be great to know what other groups exist and to have a way to get in touch with them." - Volunteer - Dublin Community Growers, External collaborator. - How did implementation of these tool impact future community project development?
"Being a 'naive outsider' and part of TURAS catalysed the collaborations.website as I worked with communities that had the freedom to implement it without the hierarchical pitfalls." - Johanna Varghese - Dublin City Council.
Lessons learnt:
Key lessons learned
Website for collaboration - Dublin
Sharing knowledge and bringing together diverse perspectives on Dublin's future.
Connect the dots - Observation for Colab
Encourage collaboration by bringing together diverse perspectives on Dublin and its desired future.
Reusing Dublin
Discovering and sharing information about vacant or underused spaces in Dublin.
Discovering Community Resources - Dublin
Activating commuity based projects in a deprived neighbourhood, Mountjoy Square.
Organisations:
TURAS (Expert - Myles Farrell, Local Authority Urban Planner)
Partner: DCC - Dublin City Council
Contacts:
Expert - Myles Farrell, Local Authority Urban Planner
Publications and reports:
TURAS tools to help understand the system:
TURAS tools to help develop a shared vision:
TURAS tools to help develop a strategy:
TURAS tools to implement transition activities:
- Communities Directory
- Ready 4 Climate Change
- PSS Toolkit
- Revitalizing Spaces
- Urban Waste Management
- CIC!
- GIS 4 Public
- 4C Transitions
- Space Engagers
TURAS Intergrated Projects which can be implemented to initiate local transition:
Other TURAS Pilots which inspire local transition: