The critical social sciences (i.e. approaches within the social sciences that examine how power, inequality, and social structures shape society) have been quite vocal in arguing for more complex understandings of the functioning of SPSIs, which would likely be supported by anyone who has experienced frustrations acting within these interfaces.
A clear example of this is the topic of climate change. The information about it has been around for decades with near unanimity about the need to act amongst scientists and other knowledge holders and yet the actions corresponding to the gravity of the situation are still lacking. This lack can be partly explained with the Homo economicus model, as the leaders can be seen prioritising their short term electoral cycle linked gains, focusing on their personal needs and maximising profits. An even more dire situation can be observed in the biodiversity field, where we cannot conform to one, easily communicated numerical policy goal.
Therefore, it is important to recognise that social dimensions frame any concept with which people interact, with the perceptions and attitudes that the first module touched upon providing the basis for such an interrogation.
The Cognitive Hierarchy Theory
How Deep-Seated Values and Beliefs Shape Our Perceptions and Actions
However, attitudes and perceptions are just a part of different cognitions with which psychology operates, which also include values, beliefs, worldviews, behaviours, and norms and they all interact with each other. So according to the Theory of Cognitive Hierarchy, we have values as the basis of human cognitive elements.
Values
Values are like organising principles and hold considerable influence over the way people behave and they also directly influence our beliefs. They do function as foundations for who we are as individuals. We tend to develop them as we grow up. They are usually relatively few in number and they are extremely hard to change. For example, these are deep, stable principles like personal commitments to equality, freedom, security, environmental protection, or traditions.
Beliefs
Beliefs are subsets of knowledge, which are linked to available information and, importantly, the relationships we form as individuals. People often seek knowledge from their networks, people, and assessments they are already familiar with. Shortly, beliefs are what people think is true about the world, like:
- Climate change is caused by human activities
- Technology will solve most environmental issues
- Biodiversity crisis is the greatest of environmental crises
While not part of the original theory, considerable literature exists linking beliefs with worldviews, which have been described as lenses through which we interpret the surrounding world and provide us with an ordered and coherent conception of the reality around us. It is here that different conceptions of the same reality can form between people. These can be for example the conviction that humans are a part of nature, therefore solutions need to be found which account for people living in nature and can mean opposition to strict protection.
It is only then, on the basis of our values and beliefs that attitudes and perceptions form. Compared to values and beliefs, which tend to be few in number and extremely difficult to change, while transcending different situations, the attitudes and perceptions can be more numerous, specific to different situations and can change more readily. Attitudes are either positive or negative evaluations of objects and issues (e.g., support for wind farms, opposition to single-use plastics), while perceptions refer to how each individual inteprets experiences (closely linked to opinions). Which then also means that they also inform an even wider range of possible behaviours that we as humans exhibit. Behaviours as such are then the observable actions of individuals and societies.
The main point here is, that the key to understanding how people will perceive the incoming information does not depend just on the reliability and communicative aspects of the data or not even on their attitudes and perceptions, but more deep seated values and beliefs.
All these cognitive elements that we talked about have been combined into a number of different concepts that have been called social constructions, frames, worldviews, cognitive frames, representations, maps, models or processes of psychological information processing and interpretation. All these concepts refer to personal constructs in which one‘s mental processes can run in. That is to say that everytime any one of us tries to understand something, we construct an interpretation that fits with our existing cognitive elements best and as such conforms to our existing values, beliefs, and worldviews.
Bear Attack!
You read the daily news and come across a short excerpt in the local newspaper from a region where large carnivores are still in favourable conservation status, reading: „Last night, a local hunter was attacked by a female bear in the forest. Neither the hunter, nor the bear suffered any significant physical injuries from the encounter. We are still waiting on the official response from the State on what will be done about this incident.“ What is your first reaction to this? Who is to blame (if anyone is to blame)? What should be the reaction of the State?
Choose from the following options...
A
The bear has obviously came too close to human habitation, the State should consider the intervention cull immediately.
B
What was hunter doing out in the middle of the forest in the middle of the night? He probably stumbled across a den and scared the poor bear. Good that nobody was hurt. The animals also need their peace.
C
The only way to coexist with bears is to minimise interactions between them and the people. The annual, preventive culls should be increased to reduce their population.
D
This makes me afraid for my own safety when I am out in the forest. What if I come across a bear unaware and the results are worse than this?
Answer explanation
All answers were sourced from talking with people about the human-bear conflict in Central Europe and all are real. Based on people's worldviews and beliefs (bears are an inherent part of our nature and we live in their habitat vs humans should be protected and bears should be managed for the risk they pose to human communities), past experiences (living in the bear country and having had negative experiences vs living far away), and other cognitions affect what kind of snap judgement of the incoming information we make.