To analyse power in participatory processes, we use a framework adapted from Just Associates, Gaventa, and the Power Cube. This framework breaks power down into four key dimensions: Arenas, Expressions, Spaces, and Levels.
Arenas of Power: Where does power operate?
Arenas of power help us understand where power is in dispute and help us to unpack the different ways in which power operates, ranging from the visible to the deeply embedded.
Visible Power: making and enforcing the rules
How and how far is power exerted through formal and observable means, such as official authority and decision-making, formal rules making, and enforcement?
Example : In the Calakmul jaguar conservation project (Mexico), the legal framework protecting jaguars (fines, imprisonment) is visible power.
Hidden Power: influencing and setting the agenda
To what extent are some people exerting power by strategically acting behind the scene to assert their interests and influence public agendas, for example by exerting pressure, excluding some actors and their concerns, or creating alliances, whether visible or hidden ?
Example from the Juaguar case study: Behind-the-scenes negotiations between NGOs regarding who has the "priority" to protect a species, or friendship networks determining who is invited to a workshop.
Invisible Power: shaping norms and beliefs
To what extent do existing beliefs, social norms, and culture generate, consciously or not, bias against or in favor of some people, creating prejudices and preventing some people from heard and seen for what they are?
Example from the jaguar case study: During workshops, vets (scientists) often answered questions meant for farmers, reflecting an invisible norm that scientific knowledge supersedes local experience and ecological knowledge.
Systemic Power: defining the logic of all structures and relationships
To what extent do existing beliefs, social norms and culture generate, consciously or not, bias against or in favor of some people, creating prejudices and preventing some people from heard and seen for what they are?
Example from the jaguar case study: The project itself was built on a Western vision of nature conservation, which influenced every interaction, even if unintentionally.
Question
Think back to this situation where you felt powerless and that you wrote down. Which arena of power seemed most influential in shaping what happened?
There is no right answer, this is based on your experience.
- A - Visible Power (Formal authority/rules)
- B - Hidden Power (Informal alliances/agenda setting)
- C - Invisible Power (Norms/beliefs)
- D - Systemic Power (Deep structural arrangements)
Answer reveal
When asked, most respondants often initially identify Visible Power because it is the most obvious constraint. However, upon reflection, Systemic Power (e.g., gender dynamics where women feel less entitled to speak) and Hidden Power (what happens between meetings) are often equally or more influential.