Features of the Game
Time: min. 90 minutes
Players: 5 – 10
Level: medium
Facilitator: yes
Format: card game (88+ cards)
Reproduction: easy
Replay option: through the variety of combinations
Materials:
- 15 Role Cards: science, policy & society
- 31 Human Factor Cards: science, policy, society
- 15 Biodiversity Crisis Cards
- 9 Debriefing Cards
- 6 ‘Vote’ slips for the support blocks
- 9 Player Support Cards and 3 Facilitator Support Cards
- 9 sets in a different colour of 3 different sized avatars per player, each set of 3 avatars has 6 support blocks in corresponding colour.
- Small paper and pen: for each player.
- 6 tokens numbered 1 to 6
- 1 regular/classic dice
Note: when self-producing: avatars and support blocks can be easily organised with e.g. different eurocents, bottle caps, different coloured paper (e.g. sticky notes) or other creative objects.
Your role
You are the “game master”, you explain the rules, the game mechanism and organise the debriefing.
For this game to be successful, you need as facilitator to maximise interaction between players, make sure everyone understands the rules, summarise what happens, and lead the debriefing.
Below you will find suggestions on how to guide your players through “Human Factor”. There is also a separate Facilitator Card with summarised reminders.
Preparing the game
- Take care of the setting: depending on the number of players, have a table and comfortable chairs. Make sure everyone can see each one.
- Check if there is enough light, fresh air, and avoid too noisy places. The setting and environment influence the mindset.
- Review for yourself calmy the rules and order of play. Take notes for yourself.
- Prepare the different card decks, and place them in the order you will use them: Role Cards – Human Factor Cards – Crisis Cards + Vote slips – Player Support Cards – Facilitator Cards & Debriefing Cards.
- Place the different avatars with support blocks ready.
- Make sure every player has a small piece of paper and pen.
- Have a timer ready (cell phone or any pomodoro timer).
The different cards
The game is composed of 8 types of cards. This is the basic set. You’re warmly invited to create more cards, in case more adapted for your specific event.
Role Cards: there are 15 Role Cards, 5 of each Science, Society and Policy. These cards have a general description of the person, without highlighting certain behaviours or tendencies. These cards are displayed openly once they enter in the game.
Human Factor Cards: there are in total 31 cards, which explain certain behaviours, The cards belonging to Science, Society of Policy field, are in the same colour as the respective Role Cards. These cards, once taken by the player, remains hidden till the end of the activity (unless players reveal this themselves by own choice).
Crisis Cards: 15 crisis cards, 5 of each Marine, Terrestrial and Freshwater. They describe a real current situation, and possible consequences if this crisis would be solved.
Vote Slips: 6 of those. They are placed next to the chosen Crisis Cards and have 3 sections (Policy - Science – Society) where players can place their Support Blocks during the activity, according to their role.
Player Support Cards: 9 same cards which can be given -if needed- to each player as a support during the activity. They contain a summary of the game flow.
Facilitator Support Cards: 3 bigger cards which serve as additional support for the ‘game master’ during the ‘preparation’, ‘start’ and ‘debriefing’.
Debriefing Cards: they are numbered from 1 to 9, and placed in a logic sequence. Feel free to skip certain questions in case this was already dealt with during the activity. The debriefing cards follow the flow of Feelings à Facts à Findings à Future.
Token Cards: 6 smaller cards, numbered from 1 to 6. These are used at the end to visualize the final result in the prioritisation of the different crises.
Game flow
STEP 1: The warming up kick off
Have all the players sitting comfortable around, by preference, a big squared table.
Welcome the players and clarify the time available for playing, including a debriefing. This puts players at ease and timeframes the activity.
Start with a few warming up questions as:
- Has anyone played a role game before?
- If yes, how would you describe a role game in few words?
Tell that you will be the ‘game master’ and guide them through the different steps of the upcoming adventure.
NOTE:
- If time allows, additional questions support the upcoming roleplay. E.g., “For those who had previous experience with roleplays, what would you define as the most challenging aspect? And which would be the most exciting element in such a roleplay?”
STEP 2: Explain the objective
The goal of this game is to explore and understand how human factors interact in our collective management of environmental crises.
The goals for the players are to
- appropriate the role and hidden characteristics;
- place resources and debate in order to get the final result as close as possible of your own desired result;
- interact with the other players (to influence, convince, cooperate, and more);
- define which learning each one is taking from this gamified exercise.
STEP 3: Explain the game
Human Factor is a role playing game taking place in the real world. You will be given a public role and a personal characteristic and will then be presented with different biodiversity crises.
First, you will have to write down, just for you, in which order you’d like those crises to be solved, based on your fictional backstory and influenced by your ‘Human Factor’ characteristic.
Then one player after the other, you will have two turns, to allocate resources, linked to your Role Card, to steer the order of resolution of the crises towards the order of your secret agenda. In between the 2 turns, there is some time for informal negotiations between different players.
Solving those crises will have different possible outcomes, indicated on each Crisis Card.
We invite you to get into the roleplay, argue your decision based on your role, affected by your Human Factor, and guided by your defined crisis order/agenda.
We encourage you to interact with other players, whenever you want, and influence their decisions, question their motives. Be mindful of others, wait for them to finish talking before asking a question.
STEP 4: Let's get roles
Every player takes on their turn randomly a Role Card from the stack. They read out who they are The Role Card is then placed visibly in front of the player. Continue till all players have a Role Card. Put the rest of the Role Cards aside.
NOTE:
- Make sure you have the 3 different actors in the game. E.g. if all players so far have taken ‘Science’, then the last 2 players are obliged to take a ‘Policy’ and ‘Society’ Role Card.
- From now on, the players are called by their ‘new’ name according to their role and character. E.g., ‘Prof. M’.
STEP 5: Human factor
Ask every player to take a Human Factor Card in the same colour as their Role Card. The information on this card is kept, preferentially, hidden for the other players; it defines certain characteristics, behaviours and/or tendencies of the role each player now assumes.
Tell the players they can now, based upon their role combined with their Human Factor, choose an avatar style. Give now to each player the 3 avatars of different sizes and the number of support blocks indicated on their card.
The players place the 3 avatars next to their Role Card.
NOTE:
- When players ask what to do with the 3 avatars, tell them they will be used at the end of the activity.
- In case the Human Factor received is emotionally very difficult for a player, it is possible to change this card. This is not about ‘not liking’ the characteristic, but having very personal reasons.
- If the time allows you, it is beneficial to support more ‘getting into the role and Human Factor’ by asking few questions, which each players answer silently for themselves. E.g.:
- How does your family look like?
- What makes you happy?
- How is your financial situation?
- How did you end up being a scientist, policymaker, or society stakeholder?
- What annoys you? What excites you?
STEP 6: The story
Read out the following introduction to all the players:
“You find yourself on an international biodiversity convention in the European Parliament. Many guest speakers have given inspiring testimonies. Today, the convention has planned decision making in relation to several urgent biodiversity crises. You are a group composed of Scientists, Policymakers, and Society stakeholders. As the president of the assembly, I confirm that whatever crisis ends up as number 1 will receive full attention and resources of the European Parliament, and then consecutively the other crises according to their priority definition.
The first more formal round takes place in the morning, followed by an informal lunch which allows you to have bilateral conversations. The second formal round consists of a debate leading to final decisions.
Have an exciting exchange of opinions and good decision making. It is now time to reveal the urgent crises.”
STEP 7: The crisis situations
Draw 4 to 6 crisis cards, you must have 3 different types of crisis on the table (Marine, Freshwater, and Terrestrial). Ask the players to read the situations aloud, then place the cards in the middle of the game table. Place 1‘vote’ slip next to each Crisis Card.
Tell the players to define for themselves in which priority order they -within their role combined with Human Factor- would like to see the crises dealt with. Each player writes this order secretly on a small piece of paper. Only at the end of the game, everybody will be able to compare how close they managed to influence the final priority order towards their desired order.
NOTE:
- According to the available time, take between 4 and 6 Crisis Cards. If you use more than 4 Crisis Cards in the gameplay, ask the players first to prioritise their ‘top 3’, and optionally also the others.
- The described consequences of solving a crisis, is a possible outcome and result. Concretely: there can also be other outcomes and consequences.
- If relevant, and considering the context you use Human Factor, feel free to create other scenarios.
STEP 8: The first round
First, explain how, at the end of the 3 rounds, the priority order will be defined:
- A crisis situation is supported if support blocks of all three types are placed on it.
- The supported crisis situation with the highest number of political support blocks is classified as priority 1. The second highest number = priority 2, etc.
- Unsupported crisis situations are ranked according to the presence of policy blocks, then according to the total number of support blocks.
- In case of a draw, crises are solved at the same time.
Tell that every player has up to 2 minutes to clarify their preference and make a convincing statement towards the others. According to their role's focus and Human Factor, players place 2 support blocks on 1 or more crises.
Order of speakers is decided by a dice throws:
- 1 & 2: Science
- 3 & 4: Society
- 5 & 6: Policy
IMPORTANT NOTES
- If up to 6 players, the dice can also indicate each player, which are then numbered from 1 to 6 clockwise.
- This first round is used to get into character, to see how each player plays their role, and which crisis is supported by whom and why.
- If beneficial, give to each player a ‘Player Support Card’, which gives a summary of the game overview and actions.
STEP 9: Informal lunchtime...
Tell the players that during 5 minutes, they can stand up, walk around and approach other players. This is a moment where players can approach each other, explore win-win situations, understand better the other players’ position.
NOTE:
- If you wish to increase the realism of the roleplay, don’t hesitate to provide some snacks and drinks. Be aware that this will require also more time.
- If time allows you, don’t hesitate to prolong this phase. It is an exciting moment.
STEP 8: The second round
Decide a time (e.g., 10 minutes) for an open debate. Besides placing the last support blocks, also previously placed blocks can be moved till the agreed debate time is over. Players use the rest of their support block(s) and Human Factor (extra) possibilities.
When the time is finished, announce that it is time to define the final priority order of how the different crises will be dealt with.
STEP 9: The results
See previous described how to define the priority order of the different crises. Mark the priority order with the numbered tokens (=small cards numbered 1 to 6). Ask the players to reveal their priority order and verify how was closest to the final result.
Please keep in mind that ‘winning’ is not the main purpose here. What matters here is to explore and understand how players managed (or not) to achieve their pre-defined priority order. This will happen in the next steps.
STEP 10: Deroling and demystification
Important aspect before starting to reflect on the game experience, is to step out of the role. This is the deroling phase.
- If you have objects (e.g., hat, tie) representing your role, place them on the table. Everyone is ‘back’ themselves.
- Ask each player to reveal their Human Factor.
Before going to the Debriefing Cards, ask the players to visualise:
“How much did you -as yourself- felt aligned with your role combined with the Human Factor?”
Tell them to place one of their avatars in front of them. The smaller the avatar = the lesser identification, the bigger = the more.
Invite, without a fixed order, players to comment on their choice.
STEP 11: Reflection and debriefing
Place all the avatars to the middle of the table.
This is the step where we start harvesting learning and increased awareness.
Keep in mind
Important: as facilitator, you are not a player. You have a different position and function. Do not express any judgement regarding the participants statements. When players express what they have learned, accept this. Even when it is not what you, as facilitator, expected or hoped for.
To warm up, ask the players, how much they agree with this sentence: (on a scale from 1 to 5, the higher the number, the more agreement)
“Each of us has good reasons for making our choices...
but the collective output might not be the one we expected.”
Start the debriefing by using the Debriefing cards. We suggest in the given numeric order. Skip cards if this was tackled previously or when it is less relevant for your game session and groups composition.
We propose following questions, in this order (see Debriefing Cards).
- In one word: summarise in one word: how did you feel playing this game? Describe and elaborate the moment(s) you felt this.
- Surprise: was there something which surprised you? When and what?
- Realism: how realistic were the situations and the experience? Similarities and differences?
- Take away 1: Which learning do you take from this experience?
- Imagine and share: think back to how your card influenced the way you played on different levels and share.
- Synergies: what could be done to create more synergies between the different actors?
- Now what: what do you think of the collective choice that led to this particular priority order?
- Take away 2: what do you ‘take away’ from this experience?
NOTE:
- When you are not used to facilitating debriefings or feel a bit insecure, simply follow the card order. If, at the end, it did not work out how you wished the debriefing to happen, simply blame the cards.
- Silence is not wrong, It gives the time for people to reflect and organise their thoughts and feelings to verbalise them. 10 seconds silence seems long, but it’s ok.
- Avoid starting your questions with ‘Why’, this provokes very often a defensive reply, rather than a reflective one. Formulate your -open- questions in the sense of ‘Which moments …’, ‘What are reasons that …’.
- Remember that you are a ‘facilitator’, not a player. This also means that you remain as neutral as possible. What matters here is the ‘learning and opinions’ of the players, not yours.
- Summarising and rephrasing is a good technique to make sure everyone has understood what is being shared. E.g., “Do I understand it correctly if …”, “In other words, do you mean…”
Extra
Different ways to play
PRE-DEFINED
According to the setting, topic and environment, you might decide to pre-select the involved roles and connected Human Factor Cards.
RANDOM PLAY
Give it a try, very unexpected results might lead to very interesting debriefings. Human Factor is created to remain exciting and learn-full through repetition. The many different possible combinations of roles with Human Factor Cards, the different combinations of crises, different players, number, and so much more. It remains a surprising educational activity, even through repetition.
Additional questions
If time allows, more questions might inspire for a rich exchange of ideas and opinions. E.g.,
- When knowing your role and Human Factor, did this influence the choice of your avatar style? If yes/no, please elaborate.
- If you would do this activity again, would you have a different strategy?
What if...?
Unexpected game flow
Things do not go the way you expected. No stress, no panic. Nobody, but you, knows how the game is constructed. Like a theatre play: only the actors know the script. Recover and get back on track as you feel makes most sense.
Leftover support blocks
Some players do not wish to use all their support blocks. That’s ok, just like in real life, you are not expected to support things if they are not in your interest.
A card is unclear
Clarify within the groups what is the mutual understanding. If no clear common answer, replace the card.
Curiousity
You’re curious to know the other cards, but not interested in playing the game again. Feel free to explore the other cards and engage in a discussion about them with colleagues and friends.
Running out of time
That’s a pity, but simply sometimes a reality. The game is a pre-text for the debriefing and learning part. In case this would happen anyhow, please provide the players at least with a list of questions to reflect upon.
Module 6 Structure
Facilitating the game - you are here