Both in theory and, perhaps, even more commonly in practice, the biodiversity SPSIs are conceived as fairly linear interactions, where experts, usually conceived as scientists and researchers, produce new knowledge, which is then supposed to be transmitted to the policy actors who should prepare new policies or implement existing ones in accordance with that knowledge. This conception of the interfaces is build on the assumption that scientific knowledge is objective, presenting truths about the world and its functioning, or in other words composed of facts, while the policy world, due to the principles of evidence-based policy making will take that knowledge on and act on it.
It is probably not a revelation that this system doesn‘t always work. And so over the years, a wide variety of trainings were developed to help with the transfer of knowledge from scientists and policy actors, largely focussing on how to communicate, how to write policy briefs, how to get involved in calls for evidence, how to engage on social media, how to simplify the complex scientific messages, etc. And yet, even though at least some of these topics are a core part of PhD trainings across the world, the issues with science-policy society interfaces have not yet been resolved.
And there are numerous issues that are often not addressed. A core one is that we tend to focus on natural sciences with numbers, statistics, p-values, and peer reviewed publications with high impact factors as arbiters of truth, while the predominantly qualitative social sciences, humanities, as well as the knowledges held by non-scientists, such as local and indigeneous populations, and the private sector, are not seen as equally important. Secondly, the entire interfaces are defined with preconceptions of how either experts act or what policy actors should do, which affect the way we interact with each other.
Question
How much does an average policy actor know about the evidence supporting the documents they are drafting?
Answer reveal
Policy actors might not be experts on all specific topics that they work on, although tend to be highly educated and a considerable number of them do come from research. They also tend to work extensively on particular policies and the topics they cover. Therefore, it is safe to assume they have quite a good overview about the underlying evidence. They will likely not be aware of the new developments being developed and published about right now, but will have a good grasp on the established evidence and approaches to get it.