3 Types of Policy Makers
Policy Actors
One is a perception where we don‘t distinguish between the political policy level and the civil service policy level. So policy actors only implement the political priorities, therefore any policy recommendations experts prepare should reflect the current political climate. And while this may be true for the political leadership of public institutions, most policy institutions are large institutions with lots of career officials who are there through different political cycles and continue their work.
Busy Officials
The second perception is one where policy people are seen as being incredibly busy and the only ones worth influencing, i.e. the decision-makers, are surrounded by an army of aides. For them, experts should produce short, concise policy briefs that might get picked up by aides and then passed on to the decision-makers. And while it is true that most public servants will be very busy and the leadership positions will be surrounded by aides, there are a lot of policy officers in key positions that are very likely super busy, but can be reached directly.
Good for Nothing
The final preconception is more common among the general public, who sees public servants as lazy, ineffective, drain on public money, and protected from being removed from their comfortable posts. Influencing them is then either based on loud, social activism, or they are seen as easily manipulated cogs, since they do or know nothing, so as long as you get a hold of them, convincing them won't be too hard.
The issue with most of these preconceptions, that are stemming from linear SPSI model, where experts hold the knowledge and policy is supposed to follow, is the failure to recognise that policymakers are very often highly educated (PhDs are common) and they often also come to the policy institutions from research. Therefore, they are far from tabulas rasas that they are often perceived. They have their own ideas and priorities on what should be done and how, their own agendas if you will, based on their own expertise, knowledge, and experiences. So they are not easily influenced, simply by providing new or better knowledge, that knowledge has to align with the work they are already doing. However, public institutions are very hierarchical, with lots and lots of rules that aimed at ensuring transparency and clear spending routes for public money, which makes them slow(er) at responding and each decision has to get through often complex approval processes.
Question 3
Why do policy makers sometimes ignore the available evidence when making decisions?
Explore potential answers below.
Political convenience
Sometimes this does happen. Although, the evidence isn't so much ignored in such a case, as not used. The civil servants will still take it into account, but the hierarchy above them and political level decision making, does have the power to pick and choose among the evidence bases they have available and they may choose one that is the most convenient at the time.
Limited time
Unfortunately, policy actors, especially ones working on biodiversity, do tend to be strapped for time, while trying to meet the deadlines and other commitments. Therefore, they will rarely have the time to read detailed reports or papers fully, which might make some important facts slip past them.
Disinterest
In general, it would be wrong to assume that policy actors are not interested in the evidence bases for the work they are doing, but it might be that the evidence was not presented in a way that seems relevant for what they need to do, in which case it might get ignored.
Wrong time
All too often, the evidence is made available outside the policy windows, when it can be used. All policies have defined cycles through which their implementation moves, so there are windows of opportunity when evidence can shape the decisions, but after the times for the drafting are done and the documents move into approval processes, the window closes and the document cannot be changed anymore.
Evidence is unclear
Policy actors do prefer certainty and while they recognise the inherent uncertainty in evidence, they need to see options for what they can do with the available evidence (e.g., scenarios, pathways). Simply saying that more data needs to be collected to be more certain will not work well in a fast-paced policy environment.
Misunderstanding or misinterpreting evidence
Mistakes do happen, but it has to be remembered that policy actors will engage with different evidence bases and that any data can be framed in different ways.
Answer reveal
Any of the above answers could be correct depending on the situation