The previous flow of groups through the ‘group dynamic stages’, is also influenced by the level of participation which is created or given to the different members. In this chapter, we will introduce different forms of participation.
A metaphoric story
"The life of a 11 year old young boy changed greatly during a one-week sport camp during summer holidays. He met a girl of his age with whom he connected nicely to, and so did she towards him. Secret looks and smiles to each other was the base of their starting relationship. Even though all remained innocent, for the boy it felt as he turned ‘from a boy into a man’. By the end of the camp, they decided together to write letters (with old fashion post) to each other to remain in touch.
Once back home, the boy went to the basement of the house to build a personal letterbox, which he would place on the street next to the one of his parents. After all: as a ‘man’, he feels entitled to privacy of his love life.
At the moment to start, his father came down to the basement. He acted rather nervous at start, assuming he would have the famous first ‘father-son’ talk. When inquiring what the boy was doing, the boy explained the letterbox plan. The father was visibly relieved.
‘Son’, he said, ‘you know that your father is an engineer?
‘Yes, daddy’.
‘I’ll make you a very good letterbox!’
And so the father did, an all ‘dancing and singing’ letterbox. Strong, with different great features and images carved in the wood. A true masterpiece.
What the son however never shared with his father, is that he considered his father the reason of his ‘miserable and sad’ love life ever since.”
Question 1
What is the reason the father is being blamed?
- A - The father was secretly reading the letters send to his son
- B - The father never had the ‘father-son’ talk
- C - The father wrote letters for his son instead of the girl
- D - The father built the letterbox himself
- E - The father started a relationship with the mother of the boy’s girlfriend
Answer reveal
D
With all good intentions and father love, the project and motivation of the young boy was taken away. The young boy knew that his first letterbox might probably not last long time, once he had never made one. But his ‘passion’ and motivation would lead to re-build it over and over, with made improvements. It was his little project. When his father took over, he lost ownership of his project and therefor motivation was lost.
Instead, the father could have said: “Listen son, you know daddy is an engineer. If you are interested, I can explain you the difference between a nail and a screw, different types of wood and tools. Just let me know, I’m here.”
This is a direct example related to different concepts of participation. More in the rest of this chapter.
Ladder of participation
While exploring different interpretations and levels of participation, let’s keep in mind how this has an impact on the group dynamic phases, explored previously.
The way you’re being part of a meeting or a group is also affected on what is my position in there, what is given to me to participate at which level. Understanding this contributes understanding active or rather passive presence of members in groups.
Whatever follows now, let’s keep in mind the meetings we are part of. And wonder about the following:
- Who decided the agenda.
- Who decided the timeframe.
- Who decided the place of the meeting.
- Who is making the minutes.
- Who decided at which moment of the day the meeting is planned.
To explore different formats and interpretations of participation, we have used a straightforward model developed by Roger Hart: ‘The Ladder of Participation’. In his most modest model, he defines 8 different levels of participation. We have explored this in the webinar as example, being tailored at rather young people versus adults and with a focus on agency, education and development. Here we will explore Sherry Arnstein's "Ladder of Citizen Participation", which relates also to participation as a citizen with whatever role you might have (e.g. Scientist, Society etc). With a focus on legal authority, money and power.
Let’s explore together the different steps of the ladder, from the bottom to the top.
Non-participation
- Manipulation: citizens are invited to participate on board meetings, but this is actually to "educate" them or manipulate their support for a pre-decided plan.
- Therapy: public powerholders avoid addressing expressed political issues by treating citizens' problems as the start of curing the expressed problem.
Degrees of Tokenism
- Informing: a one-way communication where citizens are told what is happening, but there is no space or opportunity to give feedback.
- Consultation: meetings, surveys and questionnaires, yet there is no assurance or guarantee that the results will be taken into account.
- Placation: citizens are invited and included in decision making boards and meetings, but they have no real vote or power to change outcomes.
Degrees of Citizen Power
- Partnership: through negotiation, citizens and powerholders share planning and decision-making responsibilities. Power is redistributed.
- Delegated Power: citizens have received specific powers, e.g. the majority of seats on a committee/meeting or having the power to veto specific aspects of a project.
- Citizen Control: have full charge of policy and management, and can negotiate the conditions under which "outsiders" (e.g. policymakers) may change them.
According the level of participation you find yourself in, your engagement in the building of a group dynamic in the meeting (see previous chapter) towards a level of ‘performing’, plays an important role. Understanding these 2 different elements in managing or being part in meetings, is therefor important. In the next chapter we explore together how ‘suppression techniques’ from any of the members, even yourself, can have negative impacts unless avoided or countered.