Below, you find a situation, select the good step of the 8 different levels on the ladder of Sherry Arnstein.
Situation 1:
"You receive a flyer spread by the local government about a new industrial park which will be built soon. There is no contact number or email provided for feedback."
- A - Manipulation
- B - Therapy
- C - Informing
- D - Consultation
- E - Placation
- F - Partnership
- G - Delegated power
- H - Citizen control
Answer reveal
C - Informing
Situation 2:
"The policymakers agreed that a project reducing pollution caused by weapon industry would move forward if the Planning Committee (made up of 50% society and science) and the Policy Board reach a joint agreement on the action timeline."
- A - Manipulation
- B - Therapy
- C - Informing
- D - Consultation
- E - Placation
- F - Partnership
- G - Delegated power
- H - Citizen control
Answer reveal
F - partnership
Situation 4
"You are invited for a public hearing concerning the decreasing number of pollinators. The authority is taking notes on the idea/complaints and gathers them in a folder. Yet, the final project plan is already written and planned and will not change regardless your contributions."
- A - Manipulation
- B - Therapy
- C - Informing
- D - Consultation
- E - Placation
- F - Partnership
- G - Delegated power
- H - Citizen control
Answer reveal
D - Consultation
Situation 5
"A group of marine experts and scientists has the legal power to veto any political decision regarding marine life, and have full control over the marine-use zoning for a defined particular area."
- A - Manipulation
- B - Therapy
- C - Informing
- D - Consultation
- E - Placation
- F - Partnership
- G - Delegated power
- H - Citizen control
Answer reveal
H - Citizen control
Situation 6
"You expressed your concern about pollution. The city has brought in experts to calm down what they define as a rather ‘psychological issue’, instead of dealing and addressing the actual risk of pollution."
- A - Manipulation
- B - Therapy
- C - Informing
- D - Consultation
- E - Placation
- F - Partnership
- G - Delegated power
- H - Citizen control
Answer reveal
B - Therapy
Situation 7
"Policymakers have given a group of scientists the total budget and authority to create and execute a 2 year intervention to safeguard a rare species in the rivers."
- A - Manipulation
- B - Therapy
- C - Informing
- D - Consultation
- E - Placation
- F - Partnership
- G - Delegated power
- H - Citizen control
Answer reveal
G - Delegated power
Situation 8
"You and 2 colleagues are invited to be part of an official 17-person ‘Biodiversity recommendations taskforce group’. Yet, the other 14 members are policymakers who outvote your 3 citizens votes when it comes to meaningful decisions."
- A - Manipulation
- B - Therapy
- C - Informing
- D - Consultation
- E - Placation
- F - Partnership
- G - Delegated power
- H - Citizen control
Answer reveal
E - Placation