Let’s now, with curious eyes, look at meetings. We will explore different small elements, which, when combined, approach this complex given from different angles. If we know more on how to read groups, we understand better how the dynamics influence the style of the meeting, positioning of different members, and eventually how decisions are made.
To explore this is an accessible manner, we use the model of Tuckman. This model has had quite some finetuning and addings by other people, yet, it is a very comprehensive and clarifying model. He identifies 5 main group dynamic phases.
If the word TEAM would be an acronym, what would it stand for? One might come up with many creative answers, but the most commonly one would be: Together Everyone Achieve More’. To reach this, several stages can be identified. When exploring these stages, we go from the point of view that the members of the team do not come with e.g. hidden agendas. We here look at a group, bigger than 2, which has come together with a common interest, on a common topic. The members have not met each other earlier and everyone is new to each other.
Tuckman identifies 5 main group dynamic phases.
Phase 1: Forming
It is reasonable to state that we all have passed through this phase, and that several times in our life already. You meet an interesting person and there is an mutual interest to start a relationship. In the first phase of such a relationship, we generally tend to show our best side, showing sympathy, being a nice person. After all: "You never get a second chance to make a first impression."
You're not going into conflict, you want to be liked.
This happens also with new bigger groups. People don't go immediately in a conflict situation but actually join each other in, for example, a task-oriented meeting.
Members are usually on their best behaviour and rather focused on themselves: how do others perceive me?
There is a careful testing of boundaries, checking ground rules, standards, and parameters. To grow to the next stage, members are aware that there is the possibility of a conflict.
Phase 2: Storming
The second phase, what happens also in a relationship, is the storming.
Members start positioning themselves and personal opinions are expressed. Power and status start shaping towards a hierarchy in the group, which might lead to struggle between different members. Exploring each one’s individual working style in teams is comfortable and exciting for some, for others this instability brings anxiety and insecurity.
In some cases you can simply find each other immediately (based on similar norms, values, etc.) and then there is no storming phase. You go and grow straight from forming to norming.
Better safe than sorry: there is a storming phase, even if small. Opinions are outed, attitudes might be judged, approved or not, and members position themselves.
Phase 3: Norming
Surviving the storming leads to settling agreed upon norms. Similar as in a relationship, you break or you continue with the relationship.
Norms are (re)set and agreed upon = normalisation of accepted and agreed upon behaviours, protocol, hierarchy, and more.
This is the moment the group moves towards a ‘team’ which is ready to enter in the next phase: Performing.
If the above doesn't happen, then there is a divorce knocking on your door. And it’s time to start the cycle again with others or a different groups composition.
Phase 4: Performing
With group roles and norms clarified and established, there is a focus on achieving the set goals and reaching success.
Phase 5: Adjourning
Many groups/teams have a limited lifespan, this with mixed feelings. The team cease to exist if the goals are reached successfully, unless new goals are agreed upon.
Unstability
The above progressive growing of a group towards a team is not a stable given. Example: in your relationship you went smoothly from forming to performing. Your decision to enlarge the family is most likely to bring you back to storming. New norms to be built on educational approach, different priority expenditures, and more.
A similar process with teams, when members leave but particularly when new members enter.
Knowing and understanding these most common phases which groups go through when growing towards a team, gives you as a facilitator on meetings an extra inside view and additional possibilities.
e.g. limited time might urge you to limit the ‘forming’ phase to enter faster in ‘storming’.
e.g. for the long term vision of team work, you might extend and deepen the storming phase in order to have fully transparent norms afterwards.